13 “Low-Sodium” Soups That Are Still Salt Traps: Unexpected Hidden Sodium Sources Revealed

Low-sodium soups have gained popularity as health-conscious consumers seek to reduce their salt intake. Many brands and recipes claim to offer flavorful alternatives with less sodium. However, not all “low-sodium” soups live up to their claims.

Some soups marketed as low in sodium may still contain significant amounts of salt, potentially misleading consumers. These products often rely on other flavor enhancers or sodium-containing ingredients to maintain taste. Understanding the true sodium content of these soups is crucial for individuals managing their salt consumption or following specific dietary guidelines.

1) Progresso Reduced Sodium Tomato Basil

A steaming bowl of tomato basil soup surrounded by fresh basil leaves and a sprinkle of black pepper on a rustic wooden table

Progresso’s Reduced Sodium Tomato Basil soup may seem like a healthier choice at first glance. The label prominently displays “reduced sodium” to attract health-conscious consumers.

Despite this marketing, the soup still contains a significant amount of salt. A single serving provides 470 mg of sodium, which is nearly 20% of the recommended daily intake.

For individuals on a low-sodium diet, this amount can quickly add up. Consuming multiple servings or pairing the soup with other salty foods could lead to exceeding daily sodium limits.

The tomato and basil flavors in this soup are designed to compensate for the reduced salt content. However, some consumers may find themselves adding extra salt to enhance the taste, negating the intended health benefits.

While lower in sodium than Progresso’s regular tomato basil soup, this “reduced sodium” version still requires careful consideration for those monitoring their salt intake. It serves as a reminder to always check nutrition labels, even on products marketed as healthier alternatives.

2) Amy’s Organic Light in Sodium Lentil Vegetable

A steaming bowl of Amy's Organic Light in Sodium Lentil Vegetable soup sits on a rustic wooden table, surrounded by fresh vegetables and a spoon

Amy’s Organic Light in Sodium Lentil Vegetable soup is marketed as a healthier alternative to traditional soups. This product contains lentils and vegetables, providing a plant-based protein source for consumers.

The soup comes in a BPA-free can, ensuring food safety and preserving freshness. It is designed to be shelf-stable until opened, making it a convenient option for pantry storage or travel.

While advertised as “light in sodium,” this soup may still contain more salt than some consumers expect. The exact sodium content should be checked on the nutrition label to determine if it aligns with individual dietary needs.

The soup is vegan-friendly and heart-healthy, appealing to those following specific diets or looking to reduce their intake of animal products. It can be a filling meal option due to its protein and fiber content from lentils and vegetables.

Consumers should be aware that “light in sodium” does not necessarily mean low-sodium. It’s important to compare the sodium levels to other soups and personal dietary guidelines when considering this product as part of a balanced diet.

3) Campbell’s Low Sodium Chicken with Noodles

A steaming bowl of low-sodium chicken noodle soup surrounded by a variety of high-sodium soup cans, creating a stark visual contrast

Campbell’s Low Sodium Chicken with Noodles soup attempts to offer a healthier alternative to its regular version. This product aims to cater to consumers seeking reduced salt intake in their diet.

Despite its “low sodium” label, this soup still contains a significant amount of salt. While it has less sodium than the original recipe, it may not meet the expectations of those on strict low-sodium diets.

The soup features chicken, noodles, and vegetables in a savory broth. Its flavor profile tries to mimic the classic chicken noodle soup taste without relying heavily on salt for seasoning.

Consumers should carefully read the nutrition label to understand the actual sodium content per serving. Comparing it to daily recommended sodium intake can help determine if it fits within individual dietary needs.

For those managing hypertension or other salt-sensitive conditions, even this reduced-sodium option may require moderation. Pairing the soup with low-sodium sides or diluting it with additional water could further reduce its salt content.

4) Pacific Foods Organic Reduced Sodium Chicken Broth

A steaming pot of Pacific Foods Organic Reduced Sodium Chicken Broth surrounded by various vegetables and herbs, with a headline reading "Low-Sodium" Soups That Are Still Salt Traps

Pacific Foods Organic Reduced Sodium Chicken Broth markets itself as a healthier alternative to regular chicken broth. The product uses organic free-range chicken and claims to have less sodium than traditional options.

While this broth does contain less sodium than some competitors, it still has a significant amount. A single cup serving typically contains around 330 mg of sodium, which is about 14% of the recommended daily intake.

For those on low-sodium diets, this amount can quickly add up when used in recipes. The broth’s rich flavor comes from seasonings and concentrated chicken stock, which contribute to its sodium content.

Pacific Foods promotes this product for use in soups, risottos, and pasta dishes. Its organic and free-range claims may appeal to health-conscious consumers.

Despite its “reduced sodium” label, this broth may not be suitable for those strictly limiting their salt intake. It’s important to carefully check nutrition labels and serving sizes when using this product in cooking.

5) Healthy Choice Chicken Noodle Soup

A steaming bowl of chicken noodle soup surrounded by low-sodium soup cans

Healthy Choice Chicken Noodle Soup may seem like a nutritious option for those watching their sodium intake. The brand’s name suggests a health-conscious product. However, this soup contains more sodium than many consumers might expect.

A single serving of Healthy Choice Chicken Noodle Soup typically has around 390 milligrams of sodium. While this is lower than some other canned soups, it still represents a significant portion of the recommended daily sodium intake.

The soup does offer some nutritional benefits. It contains chunks of white meat chicken and vegetables like carrots and celery. These ingredients provide protein and vitamins.

Despite its relatively lower sodium content compared to some competitors, this soup may not be the best choice for those on strict low-sodium diets. Consumers should carefully read the nutrition label and consider their individual dietary needs when selecting canned soups.

For those seeking truly low-sodium options, there are alternatives available with even less sodium per serving. Some brands offer chicken noodle soups with as little as 130 milligrams of sodium per serving.

6) 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Chicken Broth

A steaming pot of low-sodium chicken broth surrounded by various vegetables and herbs, with a label for "365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Chicken Broth" in the background

365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Chicken Broth is often perceived as a healthier alternative to conventional broths. This product is made with organic free-range chicken and a blend of organic vegetables, herbs, and spices.

The broth contains no added salt, which sets it apart from many other store-bought options. It provides 115 milligrams of sodium per serving, significantly less than many competitors.

While this sodium content is lower than average, it’s important to note that it still contributes to daily sodium intake. Consumers should be mindful of portion sizes and how the broth is used in recipes.

The organic ingredients may appeal to health-conscious shoppers. However, organic certification doesn’t necessarily equate to lower sodium content or superior nutritional value.

This broth can be a suitable choice for those looking to reduce their sodium intake while still enjoying the convenience of pre-made broths. It offers versatility in cooking and can be used as a base for various soups and dishes.

7) Imagine Foods Low Sodium Organic Vegetable Broth

A steaming bowl of low-sodium vegetable broth surrounded by various vegetables and herbs

Imagine Foods offers a low sodium organic vegetable broth that may appear to be a healthier alternative to regular broths. This product is marketed as a lower-salt option for consumers seeking to reduce their sodium intake.

Despite its “low sodium” label, this broth still contains a significant amount of salt. The sodium content, while lower than some conventional broths, can add up quickly when used in recipes or consumed in large quantities.

Consumers should be aware that “low sodium” does not mean sodium-free. It’s important to check the nutrition label for exact sodium content per serving. Even seemingly small amounts can contribute to daily sodium totals.

For those on strict low-sodium diets, this broth may not be suitable as a frequent ingredient. It’s crucial to consider how this product fits into an overall balanced diet and sodium intake plan.

Alternative options for reducing sodium include making homemade vegetable broth or using salt-free seasonings to add flavor to dishes. These methods provide more control over sodium content in meals.

8) Kitchen Basics Original Turkey Stock

A simmering pot of turkey stock surrounded by various vegetables and herbs, with a stack of low-sodium soup cans nearby

Kitchen Basics Original Turkey Stock is often perceived as a healthier alternative to traditional broths. However, its sodium content may surprise health-conscious consumers.

This stock contains 570 mg of sodium per cup, which is a significant amount for those monitoring their salt intake. While it provides a rich turkey flavor, it contributes substantially to daily sodium consumption.

The stock is made from turkey meat and bones, vegetables, and spices. These ingredients create a savory base for soups, gravies, and other dishes. Despite its natural ingredients, the sodium level remains high.

For individuals following a low-sodium diet, this stock may not be the best choice. It’s important to consider that many recipes call for additional salt, potentially increasing the overall sodium content of the final dish.

Consumers should be aware that “original” or regular versions of stocks often contain more sodium than their low-sodium counterparts. Reading nutrition labels carefully is crucial for making informed choices about sodium intake.

9) Trader Joe’s Organic Tomato & Roasted Red Pepper Soup

A steaming bowl of Trader Joe's soup surrounded by fresh tomatoes and roasted red peppers, with a "low-sodium" label in the background

Trader Joe’s Organic Tomato & Roasted Red Pepper Soup is marketed as a low-sodium option for health-conscious consumers. The product boasts organic ingredients and a flavorful blend of tomatoes and roasted red peppers.

Despite its “low-sodium” label, this soup still contains a significant amount of salt. While it may have less sodium than some other soups, it’s important for consumers to check the nutrition label carefully.

The addition of roasted garlic helps enhance the soup’s taste without relying solely on salt. This flavor-boosting technique is common in reduced-sodium products to maintain palatability.

For those watching their sodium intake, this soup might be a better choice than traditional tomato soups. However, it’s crucial to consider portion sizes and overall daily sodium consumption when incorporating it into a meal plan.

Pairing this soup with low-sodium sides or using it as a base for homemade recipes can help balance out its salt content. Consumers should remain aware that even “low-sodium” products may contribute significantly to daily sodium intake.

10) Health Valley Organic No Salt Added Minestrone

A steaming bowl of minestrone soup surrounded by fresh vegetables and herbs, with a "low-sodium" label prominently displayed on the can

Health Valley Organic No Salt Added Minestrone soup appears to be a healthier option at first glance. The name suggests it contains no added salt, which would be ideal for those watching their sodium intake.

However, this soup still contains some sodium naturally present in its ingredients. While likely lower than many other canned soups, it’s not completely sodium-free.

The exact sodium content can vary slightly between batches. It’s important to check the nutrition label for the most accurate information.

This minestrone soup features a mix of vegetables, beans, and pasta in a tomato-based broth. The organic ingredients may appeal to health-conscious consumers.

Despite having no added salt, the soup uses herbs and spices to enhance flavor. This approach can help maintain taste without relying on excessive sodium.

11) Muir Glen Organic No Salt Added Fire Roasted Diced Tomatoes

A can of Muir Glen Organic No Salt Added Fire Roasted Diced Tomatoes surrounded by various low-sodium soup cans

Muir Glen Organic No Salt Added Fire Roasted Diced Tomatoes may seem like a healthy choice for those watching their sodium intake. These tomatoes are indeed organic and fire-roasted, which can provide a rich, smoky flavor to dishes.

Despite the “no salt added” label, these tomatoes still contain some sodium naturally present in the fruit. A typical serving contains around 20-25 mg of sodium, which is relatively low compared to many other canned tomato products.

While this product is lower in sodium than many alternatives, it’s important to consider how it’s used in cooking. When incorporated into soups or other dishes, additional salt or high-sodium ingredients may be added, potentially increasing the overall sodium content of the final meal.

For those strictly limiting sodium intake, it’s crucial to be mindful of portion sizes and how these tomatoes are used in recipes. Pairing them with other low-sodium ingredients can help maintain a balanced approach to sodium consumption.

12) Swanson Unsalted Chicken Broth

A steaming bowl of chicken soup surrounded by scattered salt shakers and a "low-sodium" label

Swanson Unsalted Chicken Broth is marketed as a low-sodium option for health-conscious consumers. While it contains less sodium than regular chicken broth, it still has a notable amount of salt.

A one-cup serving of this broth typically contains around 130 milligrams of sodium. This is lower than many other broths, but it can still contribute significantly to daily sodium intake if used liberally in recipes.

The broth is made from chicken stock, with added vegetable extracts for flavor. It’s free from artificial flavors and preservatives, appealing to those seeking more natural food options.

Despite being labeled as “unsalted,” the broth does contain some salt. This is necessary for flavor and preservation. Consumers should be aware that “unsalted” doesn’t mean completely sodium-free.

For those on strict low-sodium diets, even this reduced-sodium option may need to be used sparingly. It’s important to consider the sodium content of all ingredients when preparing meals.

13) Pacific Foods Organic Low Sodium Beef Broth

A steaming pot of Pacific Foods Organic Low Sodium Beef Broth surrounded by various soup ingredients and a label reading "Low-Sodium."

Pacific Foods Organic Low Sodium Beef Broth appears to be a healthier alternative to regular beef broth. Despite its “low sodium” label, this product still contains a significant amount of salt.

A typical serving of this broth provides about 140 mg of sodium. While this is lower than many regular broths, it can still contribute substantially to daily sodium intake.

For individuals on strict low-sodium diets, even this reduced amount may be too high. The American Heart Association recommends no more than 2,300 mg of sodium per day for most adults.

It’s important to note that using this broth as a base for soups or other dishes can quickly increase the overall sodium content. Adding other ingredients with salt can further elevate sodium levels.

When incorporating this broth into recipes, it’s advisable to use it sparingly and balance it with fresh, low-sodium ingredients. This approach can help maintain flavor while keeping sodium intake in check.

Understanding Low-Sodium Soups

A variety of soup cans labeled as "low-sodium" but still containing high levels of salt, arranged on a shelf in a grocery store

Low-sodium soups offer a healthier alternative to their salt-laden counterparts. These options aim to reduce sodium content while maintaining flavor through other ingredients and cooking techniques.

What Makes a Soup Low-Sodium?

A soup is considered low-sodium when it contains 140 mg of sodium or less per serving. Manufacturers achieve this by:

  1. Using low-sodium broths or stocks
  2. Replacing salt with herbs and spices
  3. Incorporating natural flavor enhancers like lemon juice or vinegar
  4. Limiting processed ingredients

Many low-sodium soups rely on fresh vegetables, lean proteins, and whole grains to create depth of flavor. Some recipes use potassium chloride as a salt substitute, though this may impart a slightly different taste.

Health Implications of High Sodium

Excessive sodium intake can lead to several health issues:

  • High blood pressure
  • Increased risk of heart disease and stroke
  • Kidney problems
  • Fluid retention

The American Heart Association recommends no more than 2,300 mg of sodium per day, with an ideal limit of 1,500 mg for most adults. Consuming low-sodium soups can help individuals meet these guidelines.

Regular high-sodium diets may also mask natural food flavors, leading to decreased sensitivity to salt over time. Reducing sodium intake can help reset taste buds, allowing people to enjoy the natural flavors of foods more fully.

Hidden Sources of Sodium in Soups

Many soups labeled as “low-sodium” still contain significant amounts of salt from unexpected ingredients. Understanding these hidden sources is crucial for those monitoring their sodium intake.

Common Ingredients with High Sodium

Broths and stocks form the base of most soups and often contribute substantial sodium. Even low-sodium varieties can add up quickly. Canned tomatoes, a common ingredient in many soups, typically contain added salt as a preservative.

Cheese and dairy products used to create creamy textures also pack a sodium punch. Parmesan cheese, for instance, contains about 390 mg of sodium per ounce.

Condiments like soy sauce, fish sauce, and Worcestershire sauce are sodium-heavy flavor enhancers. Just one tablespoon of soy sauce can contain over 1,000 mg of sodium.

Cured meats such as bacon or ham, often used to add depth to soups, are notoriously high in sodium due to their processing methods.

The Role of Preservatives

Preservatives play a significant role in extending shelf life but often come at the cost of increased sodium content. Sodium benzoate and monosodium glutamate (MSG) are common preservatives in canned and packaged soups.

Disodium phosphate, another preservative, serves as both a texturizer and sodium source. It’s frequently found in processed cheese products used in creamy soups.

Sodium nitrate, used in cured meats, can find its way into soups containing ham or bacon. This preservative not only adds sodium but also helps maintain color and prevent bacterial growth.

Even “natural” preservatives like celery powder or sea salt contribute to the overall sodium content, despite sounding healthier on labels.